Menu English Ukrainian russian Home

Free technical library for hobbyists and professionals Free technical library


ENCYCLOPEDIA OF RADIO ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING
Free library / Schemes of radio-electronic and electrical devices

FAQ on speakers and subwoofers. Encyclopedia of radio electronics and electrical engineering

Free technical library

Encyclopedia of radio electronics and electrical engineering / Speakers

Comments on the article Comments on the article

Introduction

Recently, a lot of questions about speakers and subwoofers have been heard. The vast majority of answers can be found within the first three pages of any book written by professionals. The material is addressed primarily to beginners, lazy ;) and rural DIYers, prepared on the basis of books by I.A. Aldoshchina, V.K. Ioffe, partly Ephrussi, magazine publications in Wireless World, AM and (a little) personal experience. Information from the Internet and FIDOnet was NOT used. The material in no way claims to be complete coverage of the problem, but is an attempt to explain the basics of acoustics on the fingers.

Most often, the question sounds something like this: “I found a speaker, what should I do with it?”, Or “Comrade, do they say there are such subwoofers?”. Here we will consider only one solution to this problem: Make a box according to the existing speaker, with optimal parameters for low frequencies, as far as possible. This option is very different from the task of the factory designer - to pull the lower frequency of the system to the value required by the specifications

[Q] Hashel on the occasion of a large speaker without identification marks. How to find out if you can make a subwoofer out of it?

[A] Need to measure its T/S parameters. Based on these data, decide on the type of HF design.

[Q] What is T/S parameters?

[A] The minimum set of parameters for calculating the HF design proposed by Till and Small.

  • Fs - resonant frequency of the speaker without decoration
  • Qts - full quality factor of the speaker
  • Vas is the equivalent speaker volume.

    [Q] How to measure T/S parameters?

    [A] To do this, you need to assemble a circuit from a generator, a voltmeter, a resistor and a speaker under study. The speaker is connected to the output of the generator with an output voltage of several volts through a resistor with a resistance of about 1 kOhm.

    1. We remove V (F) = frequency response of the speaker resistance in the resonance region. The speaker must be in free space (away from reflective surfaces) during this measurement. We find the resistance of the speaker on direct current (it will come in handy), we record the resonance frequency in the air Fs (this is the frequency at which the voltmeter readings are maximum :), the voltmeter readings Uo at the minimum frequency (well, for example 10 Hz) and Um at the resonance frequency Fs.

    2. We find the frequencies F1 and F2, in which the curve V(F) intersects with the level V=SQRT(Vo*Vm).

    3. We find Qts=SQRT(F1*F2)*SQRT(Uo/Um) / (F2-F1) this is the total quality factor of the speaker, one might say, the most important value.

    4. To find Vas, you need to take a small closed box of volume Vc, with an opening slightly smaller than the diameter of the diffuser. Place the speaker firmly against the hole and repeat the measurements. From these measurements you will need the resonant frequency of the speaker in the cabinet Fc. We find Vas=Vc*((Fc/Fs)^2-1).

    This technique was written in the Audio Store •4 for 99. I haven't tested it.. There are others when the mechanical parameters of the head, mass, flexibility, etc. are measured.

    [Q] I now have speaker settings, what should I do with them?

    [A] When designing each speaker, it is sharpened for a certain type of acoustic design. To find out exactly what, let's look at the quality factor.

  • Qts > 1,2 are heads for open boxes, optimally 2,4
  • Qts < 0.8-1.0 - heads for closed boxes, optimally 0,7
  • Qts<0.6 - for phase inverters, optimum - 0,39
  • Qts<0.4 - for horns

    It would be more correct to sort the heads not by the quality factor, but by the value of Fs / Qts. I will cite from memory, reluctance to calculate the formulas.

  • Fs/Qts >30 (?) screen and open case
  • Fs/Qts >50 closed case
  • Fs/Qts >85
  • Fs/Qts >105 Bandpasses (bandpass resonators)

    Elasticity, meatiness, dryness, and other similar characteristics of the sound emitted by a bass speaker are largely determined by the transient response of the system formed by the speaker, low-frequency design and the environment. In order for this system to not have a surge on the impulse response, its quality factor must be less than 0,7 for systems with radiation from one side of the speaker (closed and phase inverters) and 1,93 for two-way systems (screen and open box type design)

    [Q] Where to read about open design?

    [A] Open drawers and screens are the simplest type of decoration. Advantages: ease of calculation, no increase in resonant frequency (only the type of frequency response depends on the size of the screen), almost unchanged quality factor. Disadvantages : large size of the front panel. Sufficiently competent and simple calculations of this type of design can be found in V.K. Ioffe, M.V. Lizunkov. Household acoustic systems, M., Radio and communication. 1984. Yes, and in the old radio, there are probably primitive radio amateur calculations.

    [Q] How to calculate the closed box?

    [A] There are two types of "closed box" design, infinity screen and compression gimbal. Getting into one or another category depends on the ratio of the flexibility of the speaker suspension and the air in the box, denoted by alpha (by the way, the first can be measured, and the second can be calculated and changed using filling). For an infinite screen, the ratio of flexibility is less than 3, for a compression suspension it is more than 3-4. As a first approximation, we can assume that heads with a higher quality factor are sharpened for an endless screen, with a smaller one - for a compression suspension. For a forward looking speaker, a closed infinity baffle box has more volume than a compression box. (Generally speaking, when there is a speaker, then the optimal case for it has a uniquely defined volume. Errors that occurred during the measurement of parameters and calculations can be corrected to a small extent using filling). Speakers for closed cases have powerful magnets and soft suspensions, in contrast to the heads for open boxes. The formula for the resonant frequency of the speaker in the design of the volume is V Fc \u1d Fs * SQRT (XNUMX + Vas / V), and an approximate formula connecting the resonant frequencies and quality factors of the head in the case (index "c") and in open space (index "s") Fc/Qtc=Fs/Qts

    In other words, it is possible to realize the required quality factor of the acoustic system in the only way, namely by choosing the volume of the closed box. What quality to choose? People who have not heard the sound of natural musical instruments usually choose speakers with a quality factor of more than 1,0. Speakers with such a quality factor (=1.0) have the least uneven frequency response in the low-frequency region (and what does the sound have to do with it?), At the cost of a small overshoot in the transient response. The most smooth frequency response is obtained at Q=0.7, and a completely aperiodic impulse response at Q=0.5. Nomograms for calculations can be taken in the above book.

    [Q] In articles about columns, words like "approximation according to Chebyshev, Butterworth", etc. are often found. What does this have to do with columns?

    [A] The speaker system is a high pass filter. The filter can be described by a transfer characteristic. The transfer characteristic can always be adjusted to a known function. In filter theory, several types of power functions are used, named after the mathematicians who first sucked on this or that function. The function is determined by the order (the maximum exponent, i.e. H(s)=a*S^2/(b2*S^2+b1*S+b0) has the second order) and a set of coefficients a and b (from these coefficients you can then move on to the values ​​of the real elements of the electric filter, or electromechanical parameters.) Further, when it comes to approximating the transfer characteristic by the Butterworth or Chebyshev polynomial or something else, this should be understood in such a way that the combination of the properties of the speaker and the case (or capacitances and inductances in the electric filter) turned out to be such that with the greatest accuracy the frequency and phase characteristics can be adjusted to one or another polynomial. The smoothest frequency response is obtained if it can be approximated by the Butterworth polynomial. The Chebyshev approximation is characterized by a wave-like frequency response, and a greater length of the working section (according to GOST up to -14 dB) to the lower frequencies.

    [Q] What type of approximation to choose for a phase inverter?

    [A] So, before building a simple phase inverter, you need to know the volume of the box and the tuning frequency of the phase inverter (pipe, hole, passive radiator). If we choose the smoothest frequency response as a criterion (and this is not the only possible criterion), then we get the following plate A) Qts < 0,3 - the quasi-third order curve will be the smoothest B) Qts = 0,4 - better described by Butterworth curves C) Qts > 0,5 - you will have to allow waves on the frequency response, according to Chebyshev. In case A), the phase inverter is tuned 40-80% above the resonance frequency; in case B), at the resonance frequency; in case C) below the resonance frequency. In addition, in these cases there will be a different volume of the case. In order to find the exact tuning frequencies, one must take the original formulas, which are cumbersome enough to be given here. Therefore, I send those interested to the AudioMagazin for 1999, after this educational program it will already be possible to figure it out there, or to Aldoshina's books. And even Ephrussi's articles in Radio for 69 will fit.

    Conclusion

    If after reading all this you still have a desire to rivet something yourself, then you can take some program like WinspeakerZ on the Internet: trueaudio.com/downloads/winspkse.exe and calculate it all yourself, remembering that from G .. don't do sweetie. You should not get carried away with lowering the cutoff frequency, in no case should you try to compensate for the decrease in the frequency response of the amplifier. The frequency response may even out a little bit, but the sound will be enriched with a mass of harmonics and subharmonics. On the contrary, the best results, in terms of pleasantness to the ear, can be achieved by forcibly ruining the lowest frequencies at the PA input, i.e. frequencies below the cutoff frequency of the woofer. Another note regarding phase inverters, an error in tuning the resonance frequency of a phase inverter by 20% leads to a surge or decrease in the frequency response by 3 dB.

    Yes, I almost forgot to mention subwoofers, which are actually bandpass resonators. The quality factor of the speakers for them should be even lower. The simplest bandpass is also calculable, but that's where my courtesy ends.

    Publication: cxem.net

    See other articles Section Speakers.

    Read and write useful comments on this article.

    << Back

    Latest news of science and technology, new electronics:

    Artificial leather for touch emulation 15.04.2024

    In a modern technology world where distance is becoming increasingly commonplace, maintaining connection and a sense of closeness is important. Recent developments in artificial skin by German scientists from Saarland University represent a new era in virtual interactions. German researchers from Saarland University have developed ultra-thin films that can transmit the sensation of touch over a distance. This cutting-edge technology provides new opportunities for virtual communication, especially for those who find themselves far from their loved ones. The ultra-thin films developed by the researchers, just 50 micrometers thick, can be integrated into textiles and worn like a second skin. These films act as sensors that recognize tactile signals from mom or dad, and as actuators that transmit these movements to the baby. Parents' touch to the fabric activates sensors that react to pressure and deform the ultra-thin film. This ... >>

    Petgugu Global cat litter 15.04.2024

    Taking care of pets can often be a challenge, especially when it comes to keeping your home clean. A new interesting solution from the Petgugu Global startup has been presented, which will make life easier for cat owners and help them keep their home perfectly clean and tidy. Startup Petgugu Global has unveiled a unique cat toilet that can automatically flush feces, keeping your home clean and fresh. This innovative device is equipped with various smart sensors that monitor your pet's toilet activity and activate to automatically clean after use. The device connects to the sewer system and ensures efficient waste removal without the need for intervention from the owner. Additionally, the toilet has a large flushable storage capacity, making it ideal for multi-cat households. The Petgugu cat litter bowl is designed for use with water-soluble litters and offers a range of additional ... >>

    The attractiveness of caring men 14.04.2024

    The stereotype that women prefer "bad boys" has long been widespread. However, recent research conducted by British scientists from Monash University offers a new perspective on this issue. They looked at how women responded to men's emotional responsibility and willingness to help others. The study's findings could change our understanding of what makes men attractive to women. A study conducted by scientists from Monash University leads to new findings about men's attractiveness to women. In the experiment, women were shown photographs of men with brief stories about their behavior in various situations, including their reaction to an encounter with a homeless person. Some of the men ignored the homeless man, while others helped him, such as buying him food. A study found that men who showed empathy and kindness were more attractive to women compared to men who showed empathy and kindness. ... >>

    Random news from the Archive

    Reflections on abstract topics lead to inspiration 24.07.2020

    History is rich in manifestations of "eureka": they say that scientists from Archimedes to Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein, reflecting on abstract topics, experienced impulses of inspiration. However, the mechanisms responsible for this psychological phenomenon remain unclear. Current research suggests that simply taking a break from work does not create inspiration, but activities that allow thoughts to wander are likely to favor creativity.

    This discovery was made by UC Santa Barbara psychologists Benjamin Baird and Jonathan Schooler. The researchers gave 145 undergraduate students two "unusual uses" tasks and two minutes to list as many uses as they could for everyday items such as toothpicks, coat hangers and bricks.

    When the two minutes were up, the participants were given a 12-minute break during which they rested, completed complex memory tasks requiring their full attention, or participated in non-burdensome reaction/timing tasks that helped dissipate thoughts. The fourth group of students did not have a break. Then all participants were given four tasks for unusual use, including two previously completed.

    On average, students who took part in an easy task performed 41% better on their second attempt at repeatable tasks. In contrast, students from the other three groups did not show any improvement.

    In the second round, participants who were engaged in non-burdensome activities coped with new tasks for unusual applications no better than the rest.

    In addition to the conclusion that breaks alone do not promote creative thinking, Baird's work also leads to an explanation of one of the great mysteries of psychology: why we "hang". From the point of view of evolution, the dispersion of thoughts seems to be completely inexpedient and due to the fact that it jeopardizes the effectiveness of people's physical activity. However, Baird's research shows that there are real benefits to immersing yourself in this state when thinking about difficult problems. Perhaps, when survival depended on creative solutions, it was "freezing" that rescued people.

    Other interesting news:

    ▪ New Zealand launches first space rocket

    ▪ Useful products for smokers

    ▪ Digital camera Sony DSC-R1

    ▪ Yogurt can cure depression

    ▪ The most distant object in the solar system discovered

    News feed of science and technology, new electronics

     

    Interesting materials of the Free Technical Library:

    ▪ site section Digital technology. Article selection

    ▪ article Pour out your anger. Popular expression

    ▪ article What is a hit? Detailed answer

    ▪ article Practical acquaintance with a digital microcircuit. Radio - for beginners

    ▪ article Method for measuring the saturation current of the core of an inductor, transformer or inductor. Encyclopedia of radio electronics and electrical engineering

    ▪ article Automatic charger. Encyclopedia of radio electronics and electrical engineering

    Leave your comment on this article:

    Name:


    Email (optional):


    A comment:





    All languages ​​of this page

    Home page | Library | Articles | Website map | Site Reviews

    www.diagram.com.ua

    www.diagram.com.ua
    2000-2024